When it comes to building a durable, cost-effective, and eco-friendly structure in Kenya, the choice of materials can make or break your project. Two popular options in the construction industry are Makiga Interlocking Soil Blocks (ISSBs) and Ndarugo stones. While Ndarugo stones—machine-cut quarry stones from Kiambu County—have long been a go-to for traditional masonry, Makiga Interlocking Soil Blocks are revolutionizing construction with their innovative design and sustainable benefits. In this article, we’ll explore why Makiga ISSBs are a superior choice over Ndarugo stones for homeowners, builders, and developers alike.
What Are Makiga Interlocking Soil Blocks and Ndarugo Stones?
Before diving into the comparison, let’s define these materials:
-
Makiga Interlocking Soil Blocks (ISSBs): These are compressed blocks made from a mixture of soil, a small amount of cement (5-10%), and water. Produced using manual or hydraulic presses from Makiga Engineering, ISSBs feature an interlocking design that eliminates the need for mortar in most parts of the structure.
-
Ndarugo Stones: These are natural quarry stones mined in Juja, Kiambu County, and machine-cut into uniform sizes (typically 6×9 or 9×9 inches). They’re widely used in Kenya for walling and foundations due to their strength and availability.
Now, let’s break down why Makiga ISSBs are a better choice across key factors like cost, sustainability, ease of use, and durability.
1. Cost-Effectiveness: Save More with Makiga ISSBs
Construction costs in Kenya can quickly spiral out of control, especially with rising prices for materials and labor. Here’s where Makiga Interlocking Soil Blocks shine:
-
Lower Material Costs: ISSBs are made from locally sourced soil, which is often free or inexpensive, mixed with a minimal amount of cement. Ndarugo stones, on the other hand, require quarrying, cutting, and transportation from Juja to your site, driving up costs significantly. For example, a 6×9 Ndarugo stone can cost Ksh 25-30 per piece, and a lorry load of 1,000 pieces might set you back Ksh 25,000 or more, excluding transport.
-
Reduced Labor Costs: The interlocking design of Makiga blocks eliminates the need for mortar between most joints, cutting down on cement, sand, and skilled labor expenses. Building with Ndarugo stones requires extensive mortar use and skilled masons to ensure proper alignment, adding to the overall budget.
-
On-Site Production: With a Makiga press machine, you can produce ISSBs directly at your construction site, avoiding transportation fees entirely. Ndarugo stones, however, must be hauled from the quarry, with transport costs varying based on distance (e.g., Ksh 5,000-15,000 per trip).
Verdict: Makiga ISSBs can reduce building costs by up to 30% compared to Ndarugo stones, making them ideal for budget-conscious projects.
2. Sustainability: Eco-Friendly Building with ISSBs
As the world shifts toward greener construction practices, sustainability is a critical factor in material selection. Here’s how the two stack up:
-
Makiga ISSBs: These blocks are an eco-friendly choice, utilizing locally available soil and requiring minimal cement. They don’t involve deforestation, excessive mining, or high-energy processes like quarrying. The production process has a low carbon footprint, aligning with Kenya’s push for sustainable housing.
-
Ndarugo Stones: Quarrying Ndarugo stones has a significant environmental impact. Mining disrupts landscapes, contributes to soil erosion, and increases carbon emissions due to heavy machinery and transportation. The process also depletes natural stone reserves, making it less sustainable in the long term.
Verdict: For environmentally conscious builders, Makiga ISSBs are the clear winner, offering a renewable and low-impact alternative to Ndarugo stones.
3. Ease of Installation: Faster Builds with Less Expertise
Time is money in construction, and the ease of working with materials can drastically affect project timelines.
-
Makiga ISSBs: The interlocking mechanism allows blocks to fit together like puzzle pieces, requiring minimal skill to assemble. Even individuals with little construction experience can build sturdy walls quickly. The lightweight nature of ISSBs (compared to concrete blocks) also makes them easier to handle.
-
Ndarugo Stones: While machine-cut Ndarugo stones are uniform and easier to work with than rough stones, they still require skilled masons to apply mortar, level the stones, and ensure structural integrity. This process is time-consuming and labor-intensive.
Verdict: Makiga ISSBs speed up construction and reduce reliance on highly skilled labor, saving both time and money.
4. Durability and Strength: Built to Last
A common concern with alternative materials is whether they can match the strength of traditional options like Ndarugo stones.
-
Makiga ISSBs: When properly stabilized with cement, ISSBs are incredibly strong, resistant to weather, pests, and fire. Their durability has been proven in various climates across Kenya, from rural homes to urban schools. The interlocking design also enhances structural stability by distributing loads evenly.
-
Ndarugo Stones: These stones are undeniably strong and durable, making them a reliable choice for foundations and load-bearing walls. However, their porous nature can lead to water seepage if not properly sealed, potentially weakening mortar joints over time.
Verdict: Both materials are durable, but Makiga ISSBs offer comparable strength with added resistance to environmental wear, giving them a slight edge.
5. Versatility: Adaptable Designs with ISSBs
Flexibility in construction is key, especially for unique or creative projects.
-
Makiga ISSBs: Available in straight, wide, and curved variations, ISSBs can be used for everything from homes and schools to water tanks and retaining walls. The curved blocks, in particular, enable innovative designs like circular structures, which are harder to achieve with Ndarugo stones.
-
Ndarugo Stones: While excellent for straight walls and foundations, Ndarugo stones are less adaptable for curved or unconventional designs due to their rigid shape and reliance on mortar.
Verdict: Makiga ISSBs provide greater design flexibility, making them suitable for a wider range of projects.
6. Thermal and Energy Efficiency
Comfort inside a building is just as important as its structural integrity.
-
Makiga ISSBs: These blocks have high thermal mass, meaning they retain heat in cooler months and stay cool during hot seasons. This reduces the need for artificial heating or cooling, lowering energy costs over time.
-
Ndarugo Stones: While stone walls can also regulate temperature, their performance depends heavily on thickness and insulation. Without proper plastering or additional layers, they may not match the thermal efficiency of ISSBs.
Verdict: Makiga ISSBs offer better energy efficiency, enhancing long-term comfort and savings.
Final Thoughts: Why Choose Makiga Interlocking Soil Blocks?
While Ndarugo stones have their merits—particularly their strength and familiarity in Kenyan construction—Makiga Interlocking Soil Blocks emerge as the smarter choice for modern builders. They’re more affordable, sustainable, and easier to use, all while delivering durability and versatility. Whether you’re constructing a family home, a school, or a commercial building, ISSBs provide a future-proof solution that aligns with both your budget and the planet’s needs.
Ready to make the switch? Invest in a Makiga press machine and start building smarter today. Share your thoughts in the comments below—have you used ISSBs or Ndarugo stones? Let’s discuss!